Finding the right plastic surgeon in Toronto means looking beyond marketing promises to evaluate what really matters: training, certification, experience, and how they work with patients. Toronto has some of Canada’s most credentialed surgeons, but each practice approaches patient care differently. Whether you’re considering breast surgery, facial rejuvenation, or body contouring, understanding what sets these surgeons apart helps you make a confident choice. This guide compares five leading Toronto plastic surgeons based on their credentials, specialties, patient feedback, and care philosophy.
How We Evaluated These Surgeons
This comparison focuses on objective markers of surgical expertise and patient experience. We looked at board certification status (FRCSC and ABPS), years of practice, training backgrounds, published patient reviews, specialty areas, and practice models. All surgeons listed maintain active CPSO licensure and hospital privileges. We verified credentials through professional societies including the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons, American Board of Plastic Surgery, and academic affiliations. Patient review counts reflect combined totals from Google, RealSelf, and RateMDs as of 2026. This isn’t about declaring one surgeon “best”—it’s about helping you identify the right match for your goals and comfort level.
Quick Reference Overview
McRae Plastic Surgery (Dr. Mark & Dr. Matthew McRae) – Surgeon-led care, dual board certification, two-surgeon option for complex cases
Dr. Brett Beber – Highest patient satisfaction ratings, 9,000+ procedures, boutique practice
Dr. Asif Pirani – Award-winning recognition, premium Yorkville location, integrated aesthetics
Dr. Lawrence Tong – Dual Canada-US certification, Michigan training, comprehensive patient experience focus
Dr. Quinton Chivers – Triple fellowship training, mommy makeover specialist, two GTA locations
Each brings something different to the table depending on what you’re looking for in a surgical partner.
1. McRae Plastic Surgery (Dr. Mark McRae & Dr. Matthew McRae)
Why They Stand Out: Surgeon-Led Care Model & Academic Excellence
McRae Plastic Surgery operates differently than high-volume cosmetic clinics. Both Dr. Mark and Dr. Matthew McRae are board-certified in Canada (FRCSC) and the United States (ABPS)—a combination fewer than 30% of Canadian plastic surgeons hold. They’re Associate Professors at the University of Toronto, meaning they teach the next generation of plastic surgeons while maintaining active practices.
What makes their approach unique is direct surgeon involvement from consultation through recovery. You won’t meet with a patient coordinator or nurse practitioner for your assessment—you’ll sit down with one of the surgeons who will personally perform your procedure. For complex cases, they offer a two-surgeon approach, which can reduce surgical time and improve outcomes for extensive reconstructive work or combined procedures.
Their training backgrounds span premier institutions: Dr. Mark trained at Cornell, Yale, NYU Institute of Reconstructive Plastic Surgery, and completed microsurgery training at the Buncke Clinic. Dr. Matthew’s training includes the University of Toronto and specialized fellowships in facial reconstruction and breast surgery. Both maintain hospital privileges at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto, which requires regular peer review and outcome reporting.
The practice serves patients across three locations—Toronto, Burlington, and Stoney Creek—making them accessible across the Greater Toronto Area. They specialize in facial rejuvenation (facelift, eyelid surgery, neck lift), breast surgery (augmentation, lift, reconstruction), and body contouring (tummy tuck, liposuction, mommy makeover). Their before-and-after galleries show natural-looking results rather than overdone transformations.
Quick Facts:
- Certification: FRCSC + ABPS (both surgeons)
- Training: Cornell, Yale, NYU, U of T, Buncke Clinic
- Academic Role: Associate Professors, U of T
- Hospital Privileges: St. Michael’s Hospital
- Locations: Toronto, Burlington, Stoney Creek
- Specialties: Face, breast, body contouring, reconstruction
- Care Model: Surgeon-led, low-volume, two-surgeon option
Best For: Patients who want academic-level expertise, direct surgeon involvement, and a low-volume practice model where you’re not rushed through consultations. Good fit if you’re considering complex procedures or value teaching hospital standards.
2. Dr. Brett Beber
Why He Stands Out: Highest Patient Satisfaction & Boutique Experience
Dr. Brett Beber has built his reputation on consistently excellent patient reviews. With over 500 combined five-star ratings across Google, RealSelf, and RateMDs, he maintains some of the highest satisfaction scores among Toronto plastic surgeons. Patients frequently mention feeling heard during consultations and appreciated throughout the recovery process.
He’s been in practice for 18+ years and has performed more than 9,000 procedures. His specialty areas include breast augmentation, breast lift, gynecomastia (male breast reduction), and body contouring. The practice operates as a boutique model—smaller patient volume, longer consultation times, and personalized follow-up care.
Dr. Beber is board-certified by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (FRCSC) and completed his plastic surgery training at the University of Toronto. He’s particularly known for his work with male patients seeking gynecomastia surgery, an area where many surgeons have less experience. His approach focuses on natural proportions rather than dramatic transformations.
The practice is located in central Toronto, making it accessible for downtown and midtown residents. Patients appreciate the unhurried atmosphere and the emphasis on understanding individual goals before recommending any procedure. Dr. Beber doesn’t push additional treatments and is known for being straightforward about what surgery can and can’t accomplish.
Quick Facts:
- Certification: FRCSC
- Experience: 18+ years, 9,000+ procedures
- Patient Reviews: 500+ five-star ratings
- Specialties: Breast surgery, gynecomastia, body contouring
- Practice Model: Boutique, low-volume
- Location: Central Toronto
Best For: Patients who prioritize high satisfaction ratings and a boutique practice feel. Especially good match if you’re considering breast surgery or gynecomastia treatment and want a surgeon known for taking time with patients.
3. Dr. Asif Pirani
Why He Stands Out: Award-Winning Recognition & Integrated Aesthetics
Dr. Asif Pirani brings a different dimension to plastic surgery through his integrated aesthetics approach. His practice, located in Toronto’s prestigious Yorkville neighborhood, combines surgical procedures with advanced non-surgical treatments under one roof through SKN Yorkville. This means you can address skin quality, volume loss, and surgical concerns in a coordinated treatment plan.
He’s received extensive media recognition, with features in Forbes, Fox News, and major Canadian outlets. Dr. Pirani has earned multiple industry awards for surgical outcomes and patient care. He’s board-certified (FRCSC) and completed advanced training in aesthetic and reconstructive surgery at the University of Toronto.
His surgical specialties include facial rejuvenation (facelift, rhinoplasty, eyelid surgery), breast surgery, and body contouring. What sets his practice apart is the integration of non-surgical options—laser treatments, injectable treatments, and medical-grade skincare—allowing for comprehensive facial aging management beyond surgery alone.
The Yorkville location reflects the premium positioning of the practice, with a focus on discretion and high-touch service. Patients appreciate the sophisticated environment and the ability to address multiple concerns in one location. Dr. Pirani’s approach combines surgical precision with attention to overall aesthetic harmony, considering how different treatments work together for balanced results.
Quick Facts:
- Certification: FRCSC
- Media Recognition: Forbes, Fox News, major outlets
- Awards: Multiple industry recognition
- Location: Yorkville (premium Toronto neighborhood)
- Practice: SKN Yorkville (integrated surgical + non-surgical)
- Specialties: Face, breast, body, plus non-surgical aesthetics
Best For: Patients who want a comprehensive approach combining surgical and non-surgical treatments. Good fit if you value a premium environment and appreciate coordinated treatment planning for facial aging or body contouring.
4. Dr. Lawrence Tong
Why He Stands Out: Dual Canada-US Certification & Michigan Training
Dr. Lawrence Tong holds the relatively rare distinction of dual certification by both Canadian (FRCSC) and American (ABPS) boards. He completed his plastic surgery training at the University of Michigan, one of the top US programs, and practiced in Michigan for nine years before returning to Toronto. This gives him a unique perspective shaped by both Canadian and American surgical standards.
His practice emphasizes what he calls the “complete patient experience”—not just the surgery itself, but everything surrounding it. This includes thorough pre-operative education, detailed recovery planning, and structured follow-up care. Patients mention feeling well-prepared for surgery and supported throughout the healing process.
Dr. Tong’s surgical expertise spans facial procedures (facelift, rhinoplasty, eyelid surgery), breast surgery (augmentation, lift, reduction), and body contouring (tummy tuck, liposuction). His Michigan training exposed him to high-volume trauma and reconstruction cases, which built strong technical skills that now inform his cosmetic work.
The practice is located in Toronto and serves patients across the GTA. Dr. Tong is known for realistic consultations where he’ll discuss whether surgery is the right timing for you or if other factors should be addressed first. He doesn’t rush decisions and encourages patients to take time considering their options.
Quick Facts:
- Certification: FRCSC + ABPS (dual certification)
- Training: University of Michigan
- US Experience: 9 years Michigan practice
- Focus: “Complete patient experience”
- Location: Toronto
- Specialties: Face, breast, body contouring
Best For: Patients who value dual Canadian-US certification and experience in both healthcare systems. Good match if you appreciate structured patient education and want a surgeon who emphasizes preparation and recovery planning.
5. Dr. Quinton Chivers
Why He Stands Out: Triple Fellowship Training & Post-Weight Loss Expertise
Dr. Quinton Chivers completed three fellowships after his plastic surgery residency: microsurgery, aesthetic surgery, and hair transplant surgery. This extensive post-residency training gives him advanced skills across multiple specialty areas. He’s particularly known for mommy makeover procedures and post-bariatric (after weight loss) body contouring.
After significant weight loss, either through lifestyle changes or bariatric surgery, patients often face excess skin and tissue laxity that doesn’t respond to exercise. Dr. Chivers specializes in transforming these cases through procedures like lower body lifts, thigh lifts, arm lifts, and breast lifts—often combining multiple procedures in staged operations for comprehensive results.
His mommy makeover expertise combines breast surgery (lift with or without augmentation) and tummy tuck, addressing common post-pregnancy concerns. He’s performed hundreds of these combination procedures and understands how to balance recovery time with life demands for busy parents.
Dr. Chivers is board-certified (FRCSC) and maintains two GTA locations—North York and Scarborough—making him accessible for patients across Toronto’s north and east areas. His patient reviews (hundreds of five-star ratings) frequently mention his approachable manner and willingness to answer questions throughout the surgical journey.
Quick Facts:
- Certification: FRCSC
- Fellowships: Microsurgery, Aesthetics, Hair Transplant (3 total)
- Specialties: Mommy makeover, post-bariatric, body contouring
- Locations: North York, Scarborough (2 GTA offices)
- Reviews: Hundreds of five-star ratings
Best For: Patients considering mommy makeover or post-weight loss body contouring. Good fit if you need multiple procedures and want a surgeon with specialized training in complex body contouring cases. Convenient for North/East GTA residents.
How to Choose the Right Surgeon for You
Making this decision comes down to three main factors: credentials, experience match, and personal comfort.
1. Verify Board Certification
All five surgeons listed hold FRCSC certification, which is the Canadian standard for plastic surgery. Some also hold ABPS (American board certification), which indicates additional examination and training verification. You can verify any surgeon’s status through the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons website or the CPSO registry. If a surgeon isn’t FRCSC-certified, ask why—there may be legitimate reasons, but it’s worth understanding.
2. Match Experience to Your Procedure
Not every plastic surgeon performs every procedure with the same frequency. If you’re considering gynecomastia surgery, choosing a surgeon who performs it regularly (like Dr. Beber) makes sense. For complex reconstructive breast work after cancer treatment, academic training and microsurgery skills (like the McRaes) become more relevant. For post-weight loss body contouring requiring multiple staged procedures, fellowship training in body contouring (like Dr. Chivers) matters.
Ask during consultation: “How many of these procedures do you perform annually?” and “Can I see before-and-after photos of patients with similar concerns to mine?” The answers help you understand their real-world experience with your specific case.
3. Trust Your Consultation Experience
Beyond credentials and experience, pay attention to how the consultation feels. Do you feel rushed, or does the surgeon take time to understand your goals? Are they listening to your concerns, or pushing procedures you didn’t ask about? Do they discuss risks and recovery honestly, or minimize potential complications?
A good surgeon will tell you if you’re not a candidate for a procedure, or if the timing isn’t right. They’ll explain what’s realistic for your anatomy and what surgery can’t fix. If you feel pressured, dismissed, or like you’re being sold something, trust that feeling.
Conclusion
The “best” plastic surgeon depends on what you need and value most. McRae Plastic Surgery offers surgeon-led care with academic credentials and a two-surgeon option for complex cases. Dr. Beber provides boutique experience with exceptional patient satisfaction. Dr. Pirani combines surgical expertise with integrated aesthetics in a premium setting. Dr. Tong brings dual Canada-US certification and structured patient care. Dr. Chivers offers specialized training in mommy makeover and post-weight loss contouring.
Start by scheduling consultations with surgeons whose approach matches your priorities. Most practices offer initial consultations where you can meet the surgeon, discuss your goals, and get a sense of whether it’s the right fit. The right surgeon is the one whose credentials, experience, and care philosophy align with your needs and makes you feel confident moving forward.
About the Author
